Skip to content

How to Run a Content Gap Analysis That Tells You What To Build

A seven-step content gap analysis: inventory, competitor keyword gaps, manual SERP reads, first-party demand, funnel mapping, scoring, and AI citation checks.

A content gap analysis should end with a ranked list of pages to create or rewrite, each one tied to a buyer stage, a persona and a brief a writer can start from. Most stall one step earlier, with a keyword export nobody can act on.

This guide covers how to do a content gap analysis that reaches that ranked list. The steps cover classic search gaps from Ahrefs, Semrush or Google Search Console. They also cover the gaps keyword tools miss: questions people type into your internal search, questions sales hears on calls, and prompts where ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google AI Overviews name your competitors and leave you out.

What a content gap is and the types to look for

A content gap is a topic or question your audience cares about that your website doesn't cover, or covers worse than the pages that win. Sometimes nothing exists on the topic. Sometimes a page exists and still loses to a better one.

The gap types below call for different fixes, so tag each one separately:

  • Topic gap. Competitors have a page on the subject and you have nothing.
  • Intent gap. You have a page, but it answers a different question than the searcher is asking, such as a product page trying to rank for a how-to query.
  • Quality gap. Your page matches intent but is thinner, older or harder to use than what ranks.
  • Originality gap. Your page repeats what every top result already says. Original data, first-hand experience and expert commentary close this one, and a keyword tool can't see it.

Gaps also sit at two levels, and Ahrefs separates domain-level gaps from page-level gaps. A domain-level gap means competitors cover topics you don't, while a page-level gap means you and a competitor both have a page on a topic, but theirs ranks for more keywords, usually because it goes deeper. Start at the domain level, then work down to individual pages.

A keyword gap analysis is narrower. It compares two ranking keyword lists and returns the terms you're missing. A content gap analysis treats those keywords as one input and asks what page should exist, for whom, and at which stage of the buying journey. Plenty of topics buyers care about never get typed into Google at all, which is why steps 2 and 4 below pull from sources a keyword tool can't reach.

What you need before you start

Most of this runs on free tools. Gather these before step 1:

  • Google Search Console access for the property, with as much history as it holds
  • GA4, with Site search tracking turned on
  • Ahrefs or Semrush (optional, since the free path in step 3 works at smaller scale)
  • A spreadsheet, where Google Sheets handles everything below
  • One or two written goals tied to pipeline
  • A first-draft competitor list from sales, plus room for the domains that actually rank
  • Internal search logs, sales call notes and support tickets

How to do a content gap analysis step by step

Set pipeline goals and pick direct and SERP competitors, audit existing content to avoid duplicates, pull keyword and topic gaps with Ahrefs, Semrush or a free Search Console workflow, and add gaps from internal search, sales conversations and AI answers. Then score gaps on business value, traffic potential and effort, map them by persona and funnel stage, choose new pages or rewrites, and turn the winners into briefs with result checks at 30, 60 and 90 days.

Step 1. Set goals and choose direct and SERP competitors

Write the goal as a pipeline outcome, such as more demo requests from finance leaders at mid-market companies. A traffic goal accepts every gap. A pipeline goal throws most of them out, and that filter is the point.

Competitor choice matters more than any tool setting. A gap analysis guide recommends a mix of direct, indirect and SERP competitors, because each group exposes a different kind of gap, and suggests running the comparison against the top three to four. Direct competitors sell what you sell. SERP competitors are the domains that rank for your target queries even if they never show up in a deal: publishers, review sites and adjacent vendors.

To find SERP competitors, search 10 to 20 of your core queries and note which domains keep recurring, or use your tool's competitor overlap report.

The common mistake is running the analysis against brand rivals only. A competitor your sales team fights every quarter may share almost no rankings with you. The export then comes back thin, or packed with branded terms you can't win.

Step 2. Audit your existing content

Know what you already have before you look outside. Export every indexable URL from a crawl or your sitemap. Then join GA4 landing page data and Search Console page data to the same sheet. Flag three conditions.

Thin pages answer little, overlap a sibling page, or collect impressions with almost no clicks. Declining pages need a per-page comparison. A content decay guide recommends a three-month year-over-year view of clicks, impressions and average position, because three-month windows smooth noise and year-over-year cancels seasonality. Read the three metrics together:

  • Clicks and impressions down with a worse position points to ranking decay.
  • Clicks down while impressions and position hold suggests the SERP now answers the query without a click.
  • Clicks and impressions down while position holds means demand fell.

The same guide warns that 2025 impression data is unreliable for year-over-year work. Google removed the &num=100 parameter in September 2025, and a separate logging error inflated impressions from May 2025 without the historical numbers being repaired. Clicks were not affected, so lean on clicks when 2025 falls inside your comparison window.

Cannibalizing pages show up in the Performance report. Filter by a query, open the Pages tab, and look for two or more URLs splitting clicks roughly evenly over the same period.

Do this page by page even when the dashboard looks calm. A website-wide average can hold steady while dozens of pages lose traffic, because gains elsewhere cover the losses. Use the compare view in Search Console and sort the Pages table by the Difference column to see who is falling.

Step 3. Find keyword and topic gaps with paid or free tools

Run whichever tool you own, export the result, and get every gap into one sheet.

In Ahrefs, open Content Gap under Competitive Analysis with the Keywords option selected. Enter your domain as the target and up to 10 competitors, then click Show keyword opportunities. Then tighten the result:

  • Set Competitors' positions to All competitors, or at least two ranking in the top 10, so one outlier doesn't flood the list.
  • Switch a URL to Exact URL mode for a page-level comparison.
  • For striking-distance work, set your position to 11–20 with all competitors in the top 10.
  • Exclude competitor brand names with a keyword filter, then export to CSV. Exports count against your plan's monthly export rows.

In Semrush, Keyword Gap lines up keyword profiles for up to five domains side by side. Missing shows keywords all competitors rank for and you don't, Weak shows keywords where you rank below every competitor, Untapped shows keywords at least one competitor ranks for and you don't, and Strong and Unique show your strengths. Add the position, intent and Keyword Difficulty filters, then export to Excel or CSV, keeping in mind that comparing subfolders or exact URLs requires a Guru or Business plan and exports are disabled during the trial.

Without a paid tool, Search Console plus the site: operator covers the basics. The two paths compare as follows:

Paid path (Ahrefs or Semrush)Free path (Search Console plus site:)
What it findsKeywords competitors rank for that you don't, with volume and difficultyQueries you already earn impressions for, plus topics you can confirm you lack
How to run itGap report against three or four competitors, filtered and exportedExport Performance queries and pages, flag queries in positions 5–15 with high impressions, then run site:yourdomain.com "topic" for each competitor topic
LimitsPlan row and export limitsUI export caps at 1,000 rows and omits anonymized queries, and site: shows only a sample of indexed pages
OutputCSV of gap keywordsSheet of striking-distance queries plus a list of confirmed missing topics

The 1,000-row UI cap and the anonymized-query rule come from Google, and the Search Analytics API or the Looker Studio connector raises the ceiling to 50,000 rows per day per site per search type. Treat site: results as a quick existence check. Google doesn't run its regular ranking on them and advises against using them for diagnostics.

The step is done when one sheet holds keyword, volume or impressions, competitor URL and position, and your URL and position if you have one.

Step 4. Add audience, site search and AI visibility gaps

Keyword tools only see what people type into Google. Your own visitors, your sales calls and AI answers fill in the rest.

Internal search comes first. GA4's enhanced measurement fires view_search_results when the results page URL carries q, s, search, query or keyword, and you can add your own parameter under the advanced settings.

Register search_term as a custom dimension so it appears in Explore. Registration isn't retroactive, so do it today. Search terms placed after a # in the URL won't be captured.

Zero-result searches need one more event, usually a Google Tag Manager tag that fires when the no-results message appears, or a data layer push from your developers. A term that keeps returning nothing means a missing page or a vocabulary mismatch. Searches followed by an exit or several refinements count as low-click gaps.

Then pull questions from sales call recordings, support tickets and community threads. Prospects ask about pricing models, integrations and migration risk in language that rarely shows up in a keyword tool.

AI visibility gaps need their own check:

  • Write 20 to 30 prompts the way buyers phrase them, split across category discovery, comparisons and problem-first questions.
  • Run them in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews.
  • For each run, record whether your brand appears, which competitors appear, and which URLs get cited.

A single run tells you little. An analysis of repeated ChatGPT runs found a one-off spot-check close to meaningless and put a statistically meaningful visibility score at dozens of runs per prompt, sometimes 100 or more. Run each prompt several times across a few weeks and report the share of runs that mention you as a range.

Monitoring tools such as Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit, Ahrefs Brand Radar, Profound and Peec AI automate the tracking. They record where you're missing and leave the fix to you. Log two kinds of gap here: prompts where competitors appear and you don't, and competitor pages that get cited where you have no equivalent page.

Step 5. Score and prioritize the gaps

Score each gap as business value × traffic potential ÷ effort. The math stays rough, and that's fine. The score exists to make the team argue about the right things.

Score the three inputs as follows:

  • For business value, borrow Ahrefs' business potential scale, which runs from 0 to 3. A 3 means your product is an irreplaceable answer to the problem. A 2 means it helps quite a bit. A 1 means you can only mention it in passing. A 0 means it doesn't fit at all.
  • Band traffic potential from 1 to 3 using the traffic the current number-one page gets across all its keywords.
  • Score effort from 1 (refresh an existing page) to 3 (new research, subject-matter input or design).

ICE works as an alternative. Popularized by Sean Ellis at GrowthHackers, it rates Impact, Confidence and Ease from 1 to 10 and multiplies them. The Confidence term earns its place on AI visibility gaps, where demand is harder to size.

Here is a sample gap list for an accounts payable software company, with illustrative scores:

GapBusiness value (0–3)Traffic potential (1–3)Effort (1–3)Score
AP automation vs manual invoice processing3216.0
What is three-way matching2316.0
Invoice approval workflow template3223.0
Competitor alternatives page3113.0
Accounts payable KPIs1321.5

Break ties with funnel stage. When two gaps score the same, the one closer to a buying decision goes first.

Step 6. Map each gap to the buyer journey

Placing each gap on a persona-by-stage grid shows which buyer you're serving and which buyers you're ignoring. Top-of-funnel content educates. Middle-of-funnel content supports comparison, while bottom-of-funnel content supplies validation.

This matrix template continues the accounts payable example:

PersonaTOFU (educate)MOFU (compare)BOFU (validate)
AP managerWhat is three-way matchingInvoice approval workflow templateEmpty
ControllerAccounts payable KPIsAP automation vs manual invoice processingEmpty
CFOEmptyEmptyCompetitor alternatives page

The empty cells matter as much as the filled ones. This grid shows nothing that helps an AP manager or a controller validate a purchase, and the keyword export never surfaced that gap. Add those cells to the scored list as gaps of their own.

Step 7. Decide whether to create a new page or update an existing one

Default to a rewrite whenever an existing page can carry the intent. A rewrite keeps the URL, its links and its ranking history. A new page starts from zero.

Check four things for each gap:

  • Intent match. If an existing page answers the same question, rewrite it. If the query needs a different format, such as a template rather than a product page, build a new one.
  • Existing rankings. In Search Console, filter by the query and see which page Google already shows. A page in positions 5 to 30 is a rewrite candidate.
  • URL history. Keep the URL whenever you can. If it has to change, Google's redirect documentation says a permanent redirect makes the target canonical and keeps the old URL tracked as an alternate. Google's site-move guidance says to leave redirects in place for at least a year.
  • Overlap. If two pages split the same query, merge them into the stronger one and redirect the other.

When a subtopic has search demand of its own, give it its own page. When it doesn't, expand the parent page. Change the visible date only when the content changes substantially, since Google's guidance discourages refreshing dates to make a page look fresh.

Step 8. Turn gaps into briefs and measure results

A brief turns a scored gap into something a writer can start without a meeting. The established templates from Ahrefs, Semrush and Content Marketing Institute converge on these fields:

  • Working title and primary keyword, plus secondary keywords
  • Search intent and the persona it serves
  • Funnel stage and the goal of the page
  • Outline with suggested headings
  • SERP competitors and what each one misses
  • The angle or original material that makes your page different
  • Internal links in and out
  • Call to action, sources, deadline and reviewer

Then measure on a schedule by tracking rankings and clicks from Search Console, and AI answer presence from repeated prompt runs. Expectations need to stay modest, because Ahrefs tracked 1M random URLs first seen in September 2023 and found only 1.74% reached the top 10 for any keyword within a year, and among those that did, 40.82% got there within the first month. Ahrefs suggests updating a page that is still outside the top 10 after about six months.

Use the checkpoints below for trend reading, not verdicts:

CheckpointWhat to checkWhat to do
Day 30Indexing, first impressions, early positionFix indexing or internal links if impressions are zero
Day 60Position trend, click-through rate on rewritesRewrite titles if impressions rise and clicks don't
Day 90Clicks versus the pre-launch baseline, share of AI runs that mention youKeep rewrites that moved, and schedule new pages for a six-month review

A worked content gap analysis example

All numbers in this example are illustrative. The company is a mid-market accounts payable software vendor that wants more demo requests from controllers.

The team picks two direct competitors and one SERP competitor, a finance publisher that outranks both. Ahrefs Content Gap returns about 1,800 keywords where all three competitors rank and the company doesn't, and removing branded terms and anything under 20 monthly searches leaves roughly 600. The Search Console export adds 90 striking-distance queries, GA4 shows "approval matrix" as a frequent zero-result internal search, and three prompts return competitors in Perplexity but never the company.

All of it lands in one Google Sheet with these columns:

Column groupColumns
Source dataKeyword, Volume or impressions, KD, Competitor URL, Competitor position, Your URL, Your position, Source (Ahrefs, GSC, internal search, sales, AI prompt)
ClassificationTopic cluster, Intent, Funnel stage, Persona
ScoringBusiness value, Traffic potential, Effort, Score
DecisionAction (new page or rewrite), Target URL, Owner, Status

The team then uses a PivotTable to organize the rows into decisions. Put Topic cluster in Rows and Action in Columns, add SUM of Volume, COUNTA of Keyword and AVERAGE of Score as Values, then add Funnel stage as a filter. Sorting by average score turns 600 keywords into about 35 Content Clusters, and the top one is "AP automation vs manual processing," a middle-of-funnel comparison for controllers with no existing page, so the action is new page.

The finished brief carries these entries:

  • Working title is AP automation vs manual invoice processing, with a cost and error comparison.
  • Primary keyword is "ap automation vs manual," with commercial comparison intent.
  • Persona is the controller at a 200 to 1,000 person company, at the MOFU stage.
  • The outline covers the time per invoice, exception handling, audit trail and when manual still works.
  • The angle uses the company's own anonymized processing-time data, which no competitor has.
  • Internal links point in from the three-way matching glossary page and out to the ROI calculator.
  • The call to action is a demo request.

After launch, the page sits at position 38 with about 120 weekly impressions at day 30. By day 60 it reaches position 14. At day 90 it holds position 8 with roughly 40 clicks a week, and Perplexity mentions the company in 2 to 3 of 10 runs for the comparison prompt, up from none.

Use ChatGPT for gap analysis within its limits

ChatGPT is fast at sorting the data you hand it and unreliable at producing data on its own. OpenAI's help documentation says outputs can be wrong while sounding confident, and that web search results and citations can be incomplete, outdated or incorrect. ChatGPT has no native access to search volume, rankings or your traffic, so any volume it gives you is a guess.

Paste in your exports and constrain the model to them. These three prompts follow the guardrails in Search Engine Land's AI-assisted competitor analysis workflow, which tells the model to use only the supplied keywords, never invent volume or ranking data, and mark unclear intent for manual review.

For clustering:

Here is a CSV of gap keywords with volume and KD from Ahrefs.
Group them into topic clusters where one page could rank for the whole cluster.
Use ONLY keywords in this file. Do not add keywords or change any numbers.
Return a table: cluster name, keywords, summed volume.

For intent tagging:

For each keyword below, tag the primary intent as informational,
commercial, transactional or navigational, and give a one-line reason.
If the intent is ambiguous, write "verify manually" instead of guessing.

For brief drafting:

Draft a content brief using these fields: working title, primary keyword,
intent, persona, funnel stage, outline with H2s, internal links from this
URL list, and call to action. Use only the SERP notes and URLs I provide.
If a field has no data, write "not available."

Check the output before it reaches the sheet. Search the top cluster keywords yourself to confirm one page ranks for them together, and spot-check intent labels against the live results. Match every number in the output to the source export.

Common problems that stall a gap analysis

Most gap projects stall for operational reasons, and each one has a direct fix.

  • Too many gaps comes first. A raw export of thousands of rows invites the team to treat every missing keyword as a page. Cut by pipeline goal and business value before you score anything, and keep informational utility content as a steady background effort.
  • Wrong competitors usually means brand rivals only, which produces an export that is thin or full of branded terms. Rebuild the set from the domains that actually rank for your core queries.
  • Ignoring intent burns quarters. One team described in the Search Engine Land workflow above spent an entire sprint on high-volume informational keywords that brought traffic and no leads. Score business value before traffic potential.
  • No measurement means nobody knows which pages worked, so the next analysis starts from scratch. Put the 30, 60 and 90 day checks on the calendar the day each page ships.

Data spread across disconnected tools stalls projects without anyone noticing. Search Console, GA4, a keyword tool, an AI tracker and the planning sheet each hold part of the picture, and reconciling them uses up the time meant for briefs. GrowthX Opportunities ranks create and rewrite work in one queue, drawing on Context and AI visibility gaps alongside search data. If maintaining this workflow across separate tools is the bottleneck, book a demo to see how GrowthX runs it in one workspace.

Related articles

  1. What Is an Enterprise SEO Audit and How Does It Work at Scale? Learn · 16 September 2026
  2. How to Build an SEO Strategy for a SaaS Company Learn · 11 September 2026
  3. How to find the questions your buyers ask AI Blog · 20 October 2026
  4. What a complete question map looks like Blog · 15 October 2026
  5. What question intelligence actually is Blog · 18 September 2026
  6. How to create an SEO content brief writers actually use Learn · 11 September 2026
  7. A B2B Content Strategy Framework for AI Search Learn · 14 July 2026
  8. Frameworks for Managing Content Portfolios Learn · 10 July 2026